cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Does Clickpass make OpenID more usable?

Does Clickpass make OpenID more usable?

Does Clickpass make OpenID more usable?

Clickpass has just launched a new OpenID offering which aims to make single sign-in easy enough for the masses. It takes a rather different approach to OpenID than other sites I have tried. The first obvious difference is that sites must, in addition to supporting OpenID, add a special Clickpass button to their sign-in screen. Behind the scenes it also generates a new, unique OpenID URL for each site you use. This is an interesting extra layer of privacy as it makes you completely unidetifiable to the relying party (i.e. the website you are signing in to). I gave it a whirl with Plaxo but was shocked to find that upon clicking the Clickpass button I was taken to a page on clickpass.com which asked me for my Plaxo username and password! Carsten Pötter has a more in depth post on this bizarre behaviour of Clickpass. He ends with this thought:

There have to be better solutions for making the OpenID experience more comfortable for mainstream users. OpenID is here to overcome the password dilemma of many people, even trying to be more secure. Giving away passwords to third party sites is contradictory and is giving the wrong signal to users.

A comment on that post from Clickpass boss Peter Nixey goes some way to explaining why they chose to do it that way:

We spent a lot of time talking about the ‘asking users for passwords’ problem. In actuality we don’t even pass the credentials through our server - they are submitted directly to the relying party but nonetheless is would be better not to ask for them at all.

It's true that the form goes direct to the server of the relying party (it is used to send them the randomly generated OpenID URL) but how is anyone to know that? Half the point of OpenID is avoiding sharing passwords between sites. Most users probably wouldn't think twice about entering their private login details into a third-party site (especially when presented as part of a login process) but that is exactly the kind if blind trust that we, as conciencious web developers, should be educating against. Ultimately though I think Clickpass's biggest problem will be getting sites to implement their special button. There are few enough sites that accept standard OpenIDs.

0 Thanks
2 Comments
310 Views
2 Comments
Community Veteran
I don't understand why they'd generate a unique OpenID for each site... perhaps I'm missing something.
They generate separate OpenIDs by default so that one site has no idea if you are also a specific user on another site, unless you give them permission to know this by using the same OpenID for both. It protects your identity by default unless you choose to reveal it. Seems to me to be the sensible way around.